Opening contribution…
Opening contribution…
Donghan Yu4 October 2026
✓ Submitted
✓ Reviewed
✓ On the board
This challenge is open for discussion. It cannot be adopted as a text change.
AI summary · The argument
Challenge: Score 3 threshold should not require specifically a "legislative foundation" but should accept equivalent binding legal or regulatory instruments, consistent with the pillar's "function over form" principle.
The author challenges the scoring convention for the Innovation & Enablement pillar, which currently requires a score of 3 to have both a "legislative foundation" and operational guidance. The author argues this language may unintentionally favor jurisdictions that place fintech rules in legislation over those using equally binding and durable frameworks through regulations, delegated rulemaking, licensing conditions, or enforceable supervisory instruments. The author contends that for an international index, the key question should be whether the relevant function has a clear and enforceable legal or regulatory basis and works in practice, not the particular legal form used. The author proposes keeping the high threshold for a score of 3 but allowing equivalent binding legal or regulatory instruments to satisfy the first part of the test, making the scoring rule more consistent with the pillar's stated "function over form" principle.
The challengeThe IEMI pillar says that it follows a “function over form” principle, and its scoring framework initially asks whether a legislative or regulatory basis exists. The scoring convention later says, however, that a score of 3 requires both a “legislative foundation” and operational guidance. I think this wording may unintentionally favor jurisdictions that place fintech rules in legislation over jurisdictions that establish equally binding and durable frameworks through regulations, delegated rulemaking, licensing conditions, or enforceable supervisory instruments. For an international index, the key question should be whether the relevant function has a clear and enforceable legal or regulatory basis and whether it works in practice. The score should not turn on the particular legal form a jurisdiction uses. I would keep the high threshold for a score of 3, but allow equivalent binding legal or regulatory instruments to satisfy the first part of the test. This would also make the scoring rule more consistent with the pillar’s own “function over form” principle.
On the board and under discussion. Nothing in the methodology has changed.
From the moderators
Test
Each score combines (i) whether a legislative or regulatory basis exists for the function being measured (engagement channel, authorization pathway, data-sharing mandate, or onboarding/eKYC basis) and (ii) whether that basis is operationalized in practice (published guidance, accessible pathways, demonstrated use by firms). A score of 2 anchors certainty on one of these two variables for the core mechanism described in the indicator; a score of 3 requires certainty on both — legislative foundation and operational guidance — across the full scope of the indicator. Apply this threshold definition consistently across all four indicators.Read the current passage · p03.s1031
This is a reasoned challenge, not a proposed text replacement. Discussion and endorsements cannot change the canonical methodology.
Sign in to endorse or challenge. It takes one email and no password.
Reply within an argument, quote a contributor, or link directly to a comment.
Sign in to reply. It takes one email and no password.