IEMI-1
IEMI-1
Regulatory Engagement and Innovation Enablement heading
Regulatory Engagement and Innovation Enablement
IEMI-1 retains its focus on whether effective, accessible, and connected channels exist…
IEMI-1 retains its focus on whether effective, accessible, and connected channels exist for fintechs to engage with regulators, regardless of organizational structure. The existence of a formal innovation hub alone is insufficient.
IEMI-1A:
IEMI-1A:
Regulatory Accessibility — whether engagement channels are explicitly open to new, pre-…
Regulatory Accessibility — whether engagement channels are explicitly open to new, pre-licensed, and early-stage entrants, including but not limited to pre-filing and pre-application meetings, not only to establish regulated firms, as well as whether regulators proactively engage with industry.
IEMI-1B:
IEMI-1B:
Regulatory Connectivity — whether the engagement function has direct authority and stru…
Regulatory Connectivity — whether the engagement function has direct authority and structural connectivity to operational regulatory divisions (licensing, enforcement, supervision), rather than operating as a siloed communications or government relations function.
IEMI-1C:
IEMI-1C:
Formal Determination Request Mechanism — whether firms have a documented right to ask a…
Formal Determination Request Mechanism — whether firms have a documented right to ask a specific regulatory question and receive a public or binding response (e.g., a no-action letter, formal interpretation, or classification ruling) distinct from general engagement channels and pre-filing meetings.
IEMI-1D:
IEMI-1D:
Feedback Loop and Knowledge Publication — whether the regulator systematically converts…
Feedback Loop and Knowledge Publication — whether the regulator systematically converts recurring engagement into public goods/deliverables (e.g., searchable guidance, FAQs, thematic reviews) rather than keeping all outputs confidential.
Sub-dimensions are designed to assess distinct and independently scorable aspects of th…
Sub-dimensions are designed to assess distinct and independently scorable aspects of the regulatory communication environment. Note that 1A (general regulator accessibility and pre-filing meetings) and 1C (formal requests for a specific public or binding opinion) are intentionally distinct: 1A captures the breadth of access to the regulator; 1C captures the existence of a formal right to a documented response to a specific question. 1E is scored N/A in jurisdictions with a single genuinely integrated regulator; document the basis for any N/A designation.
RegTech and SupTech elements appear within multiple sub-dimensions as features of implementation quality rather than as standalone scored items: SupTech-enabled intake and case-routing tools are evidence of operational infrastructure in 1A and 1B; a digital formal request mechanism with structured outputs is a higher-order implementation of 1C; machine-readable or API-accessible guidance is the most advanced form of knowledge publication in 1D; and shared SupTech platforms underpinning inter-agency data sharing represent the highest tier of multi-agency coordination in 1E. In each case, RegTech and SupTech features raise a score within the sub-dimension where the relevant function is already operational — they do not substitute for the underlying function. A regulator may deploy SupTech tools internally while providing little public benefit from engagement (high 1B, low 1D) or vice versa; each sub-dimension should be scored independently.
IEMI-1A: Regulator Accessibility: No dedicated channel for fintech-sector engagement; r…
IEMI-1A: Regulator Accessibility: No dedicated channel for fintech-sector engagement; regulatory access available only to established licensed firms through standard supervisory channels; no published route for pre-licensed or early-stage entrants; no mechanism for pre-filing meetings or informal pre-application engagement; no digital or technology-enabled intake for engagement requests. No evidence of proactive, regulator-initiated engagement with industry.
IEMI-1B: Regulatory Connectivity: No dedicated innovation or engagement function; regulatory access handled through standard supervisory or licensing channels with no fintech-specific routing or authority; engagement cannot influence regulatory outcomes; no technology tools in use to route or track engagement queries internally.
IEMI-1C: Formal Determination Request Mechanism: No mechanism for a firm to formally request a regulatory opinion, interpretation, or classification on a specific question about a novel business model; regulatory responses to specific firm questions are entirely at the regulator’s discretion with no published process, timeline, or response obligation; submissions must be made through generic correspondence channels with no dedicated intake.
IEMI-1D: Feedback Loop and Knowledge Publication: Regulator does not publish guidance, FAQs, or thematic reviews in response to recurring firm queries; all engagement outputs are confidential or case-specific with no public benefit; firms seeking regulatory clarity must engage individually with no accumulated public knowledge base; no machine-readable or structured regulatory guidance exists.
IEMI-1A: Regulator Accessibility: A “general inquiries” channel exists but has no dedic…
IEMI-1A: Regulator Accessibility: A “general inquiries” channel exists but has no dedicated innovation or fintech function; access is in practice limited to firms that are narrowly defined; pre-filing or pre-application engagement is available only on an ad hoc and undocumented basis with no published eligibility criteria or process; any digital intake is generic rather than fintech-specific and does not route to an innovation-centric team. Limited evidence of proactive, regulator-initiated engagement with industry.
IEMI-1B: Regulatory Connectivity: A dedicated function or team exists on paper but operates as a communications or PR layer with no documented authority over or structural connection to licensing, oversight, or enforcement divisions; outcomes of engagement are not fed back into regulatory decisions or rulemaking; any internal technology tools used are generic workflow systems rather than purpose-built SupTech for engagement management.
IEMI-1C: Formal Determination Request Mechanism: A mechanism exists in principle (e.g., formal inquiry procedure or guidance request process) but responses are discretionary, non-binding, and unpublished with no committed timelines; firms have no documented right to a response; any submission process is paper-based or uses generic email/communication infrastructure rather than a dedicated digital intake; the mechanism is distinct from general engagement or pre-filing meetings.
IEMI-1D: Feedback Loop and Knowledge Publication: Regulator has published at least one FAQ, guidance note, or thematic review in response to industry queries, but this is ad hoc rather than systematic; no published process for converting recurring queries into public guidance; published outputs are not regularly updated or organized for searchability; no machine-readable or API-accessible format for published guidance.
IEMI-1A: Regulator Accessibility: A dedicated innovation-centric engagement channel exi…
IEMI-1A: Regulator Accessibility: A dedicated innovation-centric engagement channel exists, whether an innovation office, hub, or liaison team, with a published scope and process; access is explicitly open to pre-licensed and early-stage entrants; pre-filing or pre-application meetings are available through a documented process; the channel may be supported by digital intake tool (e.g., an online application form, automated system, or a SupTech-enabled case-routing tool), though not strictly required. Evidence of proactive, regulator-initiated engagement with industry, but not on a systematic basis.
IEMI-1B: Regulatory Connectivity: The engagement function has demonstrable access to licensing and oversight divisions and can facilitate regulatory conversations across operational departments; authority is documented but may be informal; documented cases where engagement informs a licensing or supervisory outcome; the engagement function uses internal digital tools (e.g., Compliance Risk Management systems, case-management platforms, or SupTech dashboards) to route and track firm queries, though these need not be purpose-built for innovation engagement.
IEMI-1C: Formal Determination Request Mechanism: A formal request mechanism exists with a published process and committed timelines for a response to a specific regulatory question; responses are issued and a partial track record exists, though responses may not be binding or systematically published; the mechanism may be supported by a digital intake tool (e.g., an online submission form with automated acknowledgement) but responses are not machine-readable or structured for RegTech consumption.
IEMI-1D: Feedback Loop and Knowledge Publication: Regulator has a documented practice of converting recurring queries into published guidance, FAQs, or thematic reviews in at least one fintech-relevant domain; outputs are accessible and searchable through a published index or regulatory website; some evidence of periodic review and update; outputs are cited in at least one supervisory communication; guidance may be published in structured formats (e.g. HTML with tagged sections or a searchable database) though full machine-readability or API access is not yet in place.
IEMI-1A: Regulator Accessibility: Open, published, and operationally evidenced engageme…
IEMI-1A: Regulator Accessibility: Open, published, and operationally evidenced engagement channel accessible to firms at all stages; pre-filing and pre-application meetings available through a formal, documented process with published service standards; track record of engagement by new and non-licensed entrants documents in published reports, FAQs, or engagement logs; channel is supported by SupTech-enabled digital intake infrastructure (e.g., dedicated online portal, automated case-routing, or an APO-accessible submission mechanism) that ensures consistent handling and auditability of all engagement requests regardless of firm size or licensing stage. Evidence of proactive, regulator-initiated engagement with industry on a systematic basis.
IEMI-1B: Regulatory Connectivity: Formal published mandate establishing the engagement function’s authority and structural connectivity to licensing, enforcement, and oversight divisions; documented cases where engagement led to a licensing, supervisory, or rulemaking outcome; engagement function has an explicit power to escalate unresolved queries internally and to initiate regulatory guidance or rulemaking in response to recurring issues; the function deploys SupTech tools purpose-built for innovation engagement (e.g., a dedicated case-management or query-routing system with structured data fields, audit trails, and escalation workflows) enabling consistent, auditable handling of firm queries and systematic identification of recurring regulatory issues for policy follow-up.
IEMI-1C: Formal Determination Request Mechanism: A published, formal right for firms to request a regulatory opinion or interpretation on a specific question about a novel business model; binding or publicly documented response obligation with committed timelines; systematic publication of outcomes through a searchable registry of published opinions and interpretations; evidence of routine use across a range of firm types and business models; the mechanism is supported by a dedicated digital intake with structured data fields enabling SupTech-assisted routing, tracking, and response management; published opinions are issued in a structured or machine-readable format enabling RegTech-assisted compliance analysis, or the regulator has committed to a roadmap for doing so.
IEMI-1D: Feedback Loop and Knowledge Publication: Systematic, published process for converting recurring regulatory queries into public guidance, FAQs, thematic reviews, or rulemaking; guidance is updated on a defined schedule or in response to market developments; outputs are organized, searchable, and regularly cited in supervisory communications; regulator publishes annual or periodic engagement reports documenting themes, outcomes, and regulatory responses; firms can obtain regulatory clarity from published outputs without individual engagement in a majority of recurring scenarios; at least a subset of published regulatory guidance is available in a machine-readable or API-accessible format enabling RegTech-assisted compliance mapping, or the regulator has published a roadmap and timeline for achieving this; a SupTech-enabled knowledge-management system is used internally to tag, version-control, and cross-reference published guidance outputs.
1A
1A
Regulator website innovation/fintech-hub pages; published pre-filing or pre-application…
Regulator website innovation/fintech-hub pages; published pre-filing or pre-application meeting processes; engagement reports or logs documenting use by new and non-licensed entrants; published specifications for any SupTech-enabled digital intake portal or API-accessible submission mechanism.
1B
1B
Laws or mandates establishing the engagement function's authority; documented cases whe…
Laws or mandates establishing the engagement function's authority; documented cases where engagement led to a licensing, supervisory, or rulemaking outcome; escalation procedures; specifications or published descriptions of internal SupTech case-management or query-routing tools used by the engagement function.
1C
1C
Published formal request procedures, no-action letter registries, interpretation or cla…
Published formal request procedures, no-action letter registries, interpretation or classification request processes; track record of published or accessible responses; published specifications for digital intake infrastructure; any machine-readable output formats or structured opinion registries.
1D
1D
Published FAQs, guidance notes, thematic reviews, and annual engagement reports organiz…
Published FAQs, guidance notes, thematic reviews, and annual engagement reports organized by topic and accessible through a searchable index; machine-readable guidance specifications, API-accessible rulebook documentation, or published roadmaps for machine-readable guidance; SupTech knowledge-management system documentation.
A named innovation hub without evidence of operational use by new or pre-licensed entra…
A named innovation hub without evidence of operational use by new or pre-licensed entrants (published cases, FAQs, engagement logs, or response-time data) scores no higher than 1. A SupTech-enabled digital intake portal without an accessible, open, and fintech-specific engagement function behind it does not by itself raise a score above 1. Pre-filing meetings available only on an entirely ad hoc and undocumented basis also score 1.
An engagement function that provides general information but cannot escalate queries to…
An engagement function that provides general information but cannot escalate queries to licensing or oversight divisions or influence regulatory outcomes scores no higher than 1 regardless of resourcing, branding, or internal technology tools deployed. SupTech tools that logs incoming firm queries and routes them to a triage team, but has no documented pathway for escalating unresolved or substantively important queries to the operational divisions that hold regulatory authority, does not demonstrate connectivity in any meaningful sense and therefore would not raise the score above 1.
Specifically covers formal requests for a public or binding response to a specific regu…
Specifically covers formal requests for a public or binding response to a specific regulatory question and is distinct from general engagement or pre-filing meetings scored under 1A. Where a formal request mechanism exists but documented response timelines are systematically missed by more than 100% of the stated period, or responses are non-public, score conservatively and document the de jure/de facto gap. A digital intake system for formal requests that does not produce a binding or publicly documented response does not by itself raise the score above 2.
A regulator that publishes ad hoc FAQs but has no documented process for systematically…
A regulator that publishes ad hoc FAQs but has no documented process for systematically reviewing and converting recurring queries into organized, searchable guidance scores no higher than 1. The availability of machine-readable guidance can raise a score from 2 to 3 only where the underlying systematic publication process (the Score 3 trigger) is already in place; machine-readable format alone on an ad hoc basis does not qualify.
Sub-dimension scoring
Sub-dimension scoring
The anchors are written per sub-dimension, so each score cell holds one labelled block…
The anchors are written per sub-dimension, so each score cell holds one labelled block for each. Sub-dimension weights within this indicator:
IEMI-1A — [30%]
IEMI-1B — [25%]
IEMI-1C — [25%]
IEMI-1D — [20%]
The indicator carries 25% of the pillar; all four IEMI indicators are weighted equally.
IEMI-1 retains its focus on whether effective, accessible, and connected channels exist…
IEMI-1 retains its focus on whether effective, accessible, and connected channels exist for fintechs to engage with regulators, regardless of organizational structure. The existence of a formal innovation hub alone is insufficient.