Opening contribution…
Opening contribution…
Donghan Yunamed4 October 2026
✓ Submitted
✓ Reviewed
✓ On the board
Decided
On the board and open for discussion. Only a pillar owner or administrator can adopt changes.
AI summary · What this changes
Propose new pillar "Regulatory Governance & Accountability" to assess whether regulatory systems are administered transparently, accountably, consistently, and with reviewable processes.
This is a proposal to add a new pillar titled "Regulatory Governance & Accountability" with the pillar question: "Even if the rules are clear and substantively good, is the regulatory system itself administered in a transparent, accountable, consistent, and reviewable way?" The proposal focuses on the governance and administration of regulatory systems rather than the substantive content of the rules themselves. The scoring scale uses values 0, 1, 2, and 3. No specific changes to existing text are proposed; this is a new pillar addition to the framework.
Author’s reasonThe current framework evaluates the quality of rules, consumer protection, innovation, access, and resilience, but it does not separately assess how regulators exercise discretion. Clear rules can still be applied inconsistently or through opaque licensing and enforcement decisions. A governance pillar would capture whether regulatory power is exercised through transparent, reasoned, consistent, and reviewable processes.
On the board and under discussion. Nothing in the methodology has changed.
From the moderators
Test
The pillar proposed
Even if the rules are clear and substantively good, is the regulatory system itself administered in a transparent, accountable, consistent, and reviewable way?
Sign in to endorse or challenge. It takes one email and no password.
Reply within an argument, quote a contributor, or link directly to a comment.
Sign in to reply. It takes one email and no password.